The Mozart Effect debunked
From the February ‘08 issue of eSkeptic comes a feature from Will Dowd entitled The Myth of the Mozart Effect.
Dowd questions the validity of a 1993 UC Irvine research project completed by psychologist Gordon Shaw that gave rise to the belief that listening to Mozart improves IQ. An enterprising musician jumped on the idea and trademarked the term Mozart Effect in 1996.
The data was never reproduced, and troubling information began to come out of the original study. A subsequent German study found that music training did contribute to higher scores, concluding that it was the actual act of playing music that stimulated the brain, rather than passively listening to it. Not only that, positive effects were positive only because the participant was predisposed to enjoy that genre of music.
This is a cracking good read, illustrating how a flawed study can generate a copyrighted product, a popular myth fueled by the media, and a blind belief that is next to impossible to eradicate from the collective consciousness.
I prefer to listen to Mozart well away from men in white coats.
Tags: , eSkeptic, mozart, The Mozart Effect, Will DowdRelated Stories
POSTED IN: Ethnomusicology, Music history and theory, Performance practices, Reviews, musicology
0 opinions for The Mozart Effect debunked
No one has left a comment yet. You know what this means, right? You could be first!
Have an opinion? Leave a comment: